Each of the recipes only require you to catch the fish needed for cooking the meal. You don't have to collect anything else. Your success with cooking will be determined by the recipe's difficulty and your own cooking skill. Even at the highest cooking skill level you can't create a Rank 1 dish 100% of the time.

Recipe	Rank	Skill Points	Location	Price	HP
Butter Grilled Iwana	4	+1	Mountain (GS) Field (GS) Rapids (GS) Sister starting recipe	700 G	5
Smelt Tempura	4	+1	Mountain (GS) Field (GS) Mother starting recipe	600 G	5
Rainbow Trout Meuniere	4	+1	Stream (GS) Mountain (GS)	300 G	5
Sweet Stewed Honmoroko	4	+2	Mountain (GS)	700 G	5
Catfish Miso Soup	3	+2	Field (GS)	700 G	5
Fried Kajika	3	+2	Mountain (GS) Brother starting recipe	600 G	10
Salt Grilled Ayu	3	+2	Stream (GS) Mountain (GS) Your New Rival errand, Stream	800 G	15
Goby Tempura	3	+3	Requires Haze fish Field (GS)	400 G	10
Stewed Motsugo	3	+3	Field (GS) Swamp (GS)	800 G	10
Raw Carp	3	+3	Field (GS) Swamp (GS)	650 G	15
Salt Grilled Salmon	3	+4	Mountain (GS)	700 G	15
Grilled Eel	2	+3	Swamp (GS)	1200 G	15
Loach Stew	2	+3	Help the Science Class errand, Field Field (GS)	1000 G	20
Butter Grilled Large Iwana	2	+4	Bottled Recipe Owner errand, Stream	n/a	20
Amago Saute	2	+5	Stream (GS) The Two Brothers errand, Field	900 G	20
Boiled Prawn	2	+5	Black Bass Infestation errand, Mountain The Great Duel event, Stream	n/a	20
Big Catfish Miso Soup	2	+6	Feed The Fisherman errand, Rapids	n/a	30
Raw King Carp	1	+7	Mamoon the Curry Chef errand, Stream	n/a	40
Suppon Juice	1	+8	Cooking Festival Finals errand, Rapids	n/a	45
Grilled Big Eel	1	+8	Naoko's Rival Ayu errand, Swamp	n/a	35
Monster Catfish Miso Soup	1	+8	Master Chef Confidence, Swamp	n/a	45
Blackened Newt	1	+10	The Great Duel errand, Stream	n/a	25